Marathon Hydration: Bottles vs Vests vs Handhelds

Hydration on long runs shouldn't be complicated, but the gear choices can be overwhelming. Handhelds, waist belts, vests, soft flasks—each has devoted fans and haters. Here's a practical guide to help you pick what actually works.

Do You Even Need to Carry Water?

First, the honest question: many runners don't need to carry anything.

When You DON'T Need to Carry

• Runs under 60-75 minutes in moderate weather
• Routes with water fountains or stores
• Races with adequate aid stations (most road marathons)
• Running from home where you can loop back

When You SHOULD Carry

• Long runs over 90 minutes without water access
• Hot or humid conditions (even shorter runs)
• Trail runs in remote areas
• Training runs where you want to practice race-day hydration
• Races without reliable aid stations

Option 1: Handheld Bottles

The simplest solution: a bottle with a hand strap. Capacities range from 10-21oz.

Pros

• Easiest to access (instant drinking)
• Lightweight
• No bounce or chafing
• Easy to refill at aid stations
• Affordable ($15-35)

Cons

• Occupies one hand (some runners hate this)
• Limited capacity (16-21oz typical)
• Can affect arm swing
• Hand can get tired on very long runs

Best For

Road runs 1-2.5 hours, marathons with aid stations, runners who want simplicity.

Our Top Picks

Option 2: Waist Belts / Hydration Belts

Belt worn around waist with one or more bottle holders. Capacities range from 10-40oz total.

Pros

• Hands stay free
• More capacity than handhelds
• Storage for phone, gels, keys
• Easy to put on/take off

Cons

• Bounce (the main complaint)
• Can ride up or shift
• Harder to access bottles while running
• Some find them uncomfortable around waist

Best For

Runners who hate carrying things in their hands but don't need vest capacity. Works better at slower paces where bounce is less noticeable.

Our Top Picks

Option 3: Hydration Vests

Backpack-style carriers with reservoir (bladder) or soft flask pockets. Capacities from 1L to 12L+.

Pros

• Highest capacity (1-2L+ of fluids)
• Hands completely free
• Room for gels, phone, layers, etc.
• Weight distributed across torso (less bounce)
• Essential for trail and ultra running

Cons

• Warmer (covers back and chest)
• Takes time to put on properly
• Pricier ($80-200+)
• Overkill for many road runs
• Can chafe if fit isn't right

Best For

Long runs 2.5+ hours, trail running, ultras, self-supported runs, hot conditions where you need more fluids.

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Soft Flasks vs. Hard Bottles vs. Bladders

Soft Flasks

Collapsible bottles that shrink as you drink. No sloshing. Popular in vests and some handhelds.

• Pros: No slosh, compresses when empty, lightweight
• Cons: Harder to clean, can taste plasticky, less durable
• Good options: Salomon Soft Flask, HydraPak SoftFlask

Hard Bottles

Traditional rigid water bottles. More durable, easier to clean.

• Pros: Durable, easy to clean, fits in belt holders
• Cons: Sloshing when partially full, heavier
• Good options: Nathan insulated bottles, standard bike bottles

Bladders/Reservoirs

Large bag that sits in vest with drinking tube. High capacity.

• Pros: Highest capacity, hands-free drinking via tube
• Cons: Hard to know how much is left, harder to clean, can leak
• Good options: HydraPak, Osprey, CamelBak reservoirs

What About Sports Drinks?

You can put sports drinks in any of these, but a few considerations:

• Clean thoroughly: Sugar residue breeds bacteria. Rinse immediately after use.
• Soft flasks: Harder to clean; some runners use water only in flasks, gels for carbs
• Bladders: Most annoying to clean with sports drinks; many runners avoid
• Consider carrying mix separately: Single-serve packets + water = fresh drinks at aid stations

The Bottom Line

Start simple:

1. Under 90 minutes: You probably don't need anything
2. 90 min - 2.5 hours: A handheld bottle is plenty
3. Over 2.5 hours: Consider a light vest or try a belt first
4. Trail or ultra: Get a proper vest

The best hydration system is one you'll actually use. If carrying water feels like a chore, you'll skip it—and that's worse than any equipment choice.

Related Reading